Thursday, November 14, 2013

My Literacy Project and the Common Core Standards

This is an old piece I never got around to finishing.  I just dusted up what I had because I don't mind pointing out that the things the CCSS supposedly focus on are things that are at the heart of my teaching method.  But seriously, this whole edu-industry is bullshit at least as far as actually teaching kids is concerned.  Also, John King is a tool.  In my professional opinion.


            So the looming beast in all of this is the Common Core literacy standards.  Let me be clear, I think the language of the Common Core is another in a long wave of edu-speak quick fix movements.  As a teacher in NYC, I’ve seen a lot of these already.  It’s not a paradigm so much as a product – a diversion of funds and attention toward think tanks and privateering as a response to the a crisis that is hardly ever discussed in anything even remotely resembling useful ways.  It’s a gift to the world of what Naomi Klein calls “disaster capital” in The Shock Doctrine.  It’s a demand for more workshops and seminars to discuss not exactly how one might help students to become better educated, but something more along the lines of how we can understand what these standards want us to do in order to ostensibly educate students in the way we’re being asked to educate them.  It’s a demand, as Diane Ravitch points out, for schools to dump more money into edu-software and computer systems that don’t reduce class sizes or provide individualized learning experiences.  They provide data that can be further analyzed for additional fees.  So I’m not writing about the Common Core because I think it’s actually always good pedagogy.  I’m writing about it because it’s a material reality for educators in the same way that state exams and standardized tests are a material reality for our students.  Finding a way to appease (or fool) the beast while providing our kids with genuine educational opportunities – the original point of this blog anyway – is my focus.  




So with this caveat in mind, the video of Comissioner King and David Coleman chatting with another edu-speak talking head is really interesting and surprisingly - to be honest - a bit exciting.
 
I’m leaving aside my doubts about their claim that the solitary focus on the text “levels the playing field” as if socio-economic influences aren’t impacting the way students interact with texts.  Keep an eye out for my comments coming up on the Common Core as a New New Criticism.

With that said, there are some bullet points that directly relate to my project here and should be emphasized to shore up working room when administrators and school reviewers come around sniffing for proof of Common Core competency. 

1)  We need to correct the trend of giving students simpler materials and “translated” materials so that they can access texts.

That’s kind of the point here.  Students – not teachers – are translating difficult texts so that they can access the texts themselves.  If I want students to read Hegel, the judge’s sentences in the Scottsboro trials, or Dave Zirin’s polemic on race and freespeech for athletes, it’s because I want them to read these texts, not just receive their content. 

            2)  Students need to see access points to difficult texts, allowing them to move up in their ability to deal with more complex vocabulary, syntax, structure, and overall complexity. 

Again, that's kind of the point.  If we assume that students can find basic meaning in a text and then fill in details or just move on, then students can tackle pretty much anything.   

            3)  Students should read and re-read texts to enhance understanding, but also to look at craft and the way that authors lay out their arguments. 


Again, that’s kind of the point.  In my lesson on “Masque of theRed Death,” readers were able to make sense of the text by pushing forward and then revisiting things that didn’t make sense earlier.  When students realized that “sharp pains, and sudden dizziness, and then profuse bleeding at the pores” were symptoms, they could go revisit pestilence and conclude that it’s a disease, but – even better – they could recognize all the foreshadowing that Poe laces through the early paragraphs.    


So let's just get the kids reading.  My annotation method works.

Tuesday, July 2, 2013

To Kill a Mockingbird and Annotating Whole Novels

This is an old image - back in the early winter, when we were reading To Kill a Mockingbird.

Obviously, there's a lot of problems with annotating for comprehension when dealing with novels. On one hand, a lot of the language can be clear enough that line-by-line or even paragraph-by-paragraph annotating is unnecessary. On another, producing regular summary-based notes is even more important with novels because of the amount of info that needs to be accessibly held in some corner of active memory.

Oh yeah, and writing in school books is frowned upon but sticky notes suck.

This student just paid the 8 bucks for his own copy and we worked on a version of the annotation method that worked for him. Essentially, there are two things to focus on when annotating novels: clarifying and noting important info. In conferences, this student explained that his first note was there because the sentence threw him for a minute until he reread, and determined that the first word (Calpurnia) and the final word (smack) referred to the "me" of the narrator, Scout.  It was still early enough in the book for the narrator's "me" to be unclear for him, so "She hit Scout" was a useful way to clear up a confusing line.  It also served as a way to quickly reference this section in a Socratic Seminar later, when students discussed the characterization of Calpurnia and her relationship to the Finch family. 

The second note was probably inspired somewhat by the tone of this first note, although this student didn't say that explicitly.  However, in these early pages, a student could do much worse than to note that it is Calpurnia - a black housekeeper in the segregated South - who is at least partially responsible for teaching Scout to read and write.  The final section that is underlined illustrates the continual focus on this relationship, which was at least somewhat influenced by the method of stopping and annotating to make sense of the text.  Clearly, there are details that are glossed over on this page, but that's probably true of any individual reading led by the interest of a moment.  It's imperfect, but it's a way to begin to translate this method to the longer form of the novel.        

Rancière's Ignorant Schoolmaster: The Middle Chapters

I can only say, in the most ridiculously anti-intellectual parody possible, that I don't need this kind of mumbo jumbo.  It's one of those moments where you realize you're reading something great but the task at hand is almost completely utilitarian, so the gems slip by.  I don't have any use for 45 pages on proof of the equality of intelligence, both because I already believe in it and because my task is to encourage it, not convince others of its existence.  That sounds paradoxical, but I find that the first step should never be to tell a student that she already is smart.  Getting her to do something she thought she couldn't do and then pointing it out, that's a different story.  I'm getting bogged down in method and institutional teaching questions, but I still think there's a synthesis that can be cobbled together between Jacotot,  Rancière, and myself. 

I'm going to be teaching a course that contains a component of Latin at a brand new school in the Fall.  I have a lot of flexibility in my curriculum.  I'm looking at a literal word-for-word translation of Ovid's Metamorphosis, imagining an Animus fert dicere formas mutatas moment, akin to the Calypso could not that Jacotot began with.  We'll see we'll see . . .     

Wednesday, June 12, 2013

Rancière's Ignorant Schoolmaster: Chapter 2

I have to stop for a note on Rancière's second chapter, “The Ignorant One's Lesson.” I probably should've written something about the first chapter – something about stultification or the first mention of universal teaching maybe – but I'm not being that rigorous here.

The thing about the second chapter is that it seems to touch on my sense of a reading methodology that asks students to just read by looking at what they do understand and building from there. So often, students read a passage (we've just been working on literacy skills for science passages on the Living Environment Regents) and get to the end and say “I don't get it.” I infuriate them constantly with my stock response “Of course you do – let's look at it.” I could just as easily be saying the more brusque “Don't say that you can't. You know how to see, how to speak, you know how to show, you can remember. What more is needed?” Jacotot and Rancière agree with me - to say what is on the page is to tell me you know what it says. Meaning is strung together later out of the things you recognize. The "Red Death" had long devastated the country. No pestilence had ever been so fatal, or so hideous. The Red Death is wrecking the land. What the Red Death is and how it's wrecking the land and who the story's about and all the rest of it will come later.

Even better is the big realization for students. Rancière points out that “precisely what must be discovered is that there is nothing hidden, no words underneath words” and it is a fear of this master narrative that students must be taught to forget. Just read. It's here on the page. Of course, there's context and the call and response of text to text and polyphony and whatever other way you want to put it, but to read what's on the page is the thing in question. All the rest of that is discussion of what you could say about the text. Our goal is to read without resorting to condescension.

Is that the same sort of thing that Rancière detests? The constant holding off of more meaning from the student? Is it only in the presence of the Old Master that this unveiling of connection and context can happen? Or is there something more complicated going on here?

Probably the most relevant question I have at this point is whether or not Rancière's “Power of the Ignorant” is necessary as a condition or as a position. He claims that, for the ignorant schoolmaster, “there's no risk of this master sparing the child the time necessary to account for the word Calypso.” I fall into this sometimes – pestilence means sickness, let's move on – although I'm getting better bit by bit. But that doesn't mean that ignorance is a necessary condition, maybe. I can even imagine how a knowledgeable schoolmaster could play the role of the ignorant schoolmaster – I know it but what does that have to do with you? Or am I just justifying my position or, hell, my authority?

Wednesday, May 29, 2013

Rancière's Ignorant Schoolmaster: a First Thought from One Teacher

This is how things get messy just as Spring's turning into Summer. Months ago, a former professor read a couple of the first entries on my literacy pedagogy and suggested that I read Jacques Rancière's The Ignorant Schoolmaster a discussion about emancipation and (sort of) pedagogy, based on the teaching of Joseph Jacotot. School years being what they are, I'm just getting around to it, but it's pretty clearly important stuff. After finishing the translator's introduction, I've got to get a little bit of this out.

The thing that struck me most tonight was the notion of story telling as an antithesis to explication. Because it presumes an equality of intelligence, story telling is egalitarian, while explication is (obviously) not. I'm trying to figure out how to get my head around this on a practical level. When I first started teaching middle school, I found myself telling a lot of stories – it actually was a source of guilt – as a means of helping my students to see connections. It was certainly explication in any real sense of the word, but in a textured narrative style. It took the form of the “so you see . . .” Besides creating a human connection between myself and my students, it gave me the chance to convey knowledge as an anecdote without the presumption that I was more intelligent – just more experienced in one particular instance. In hindsight, I had much better relationships over the long run with these students than I did with students from other periods where I was less narrative (and, to be honest, less egalitarian). So there's something to story telling, surprisingly enough.

This all comes in the context of my grappling with the deskilling of teachers that is at the forefront of the effort to destroy public education and one of the last (remotely) powerful sectors of organized labor in America. I know the danger of speaking of a teacher as an equal with students because the Common Core and Danielson frameworks are being used as a cudgel throughout New York City to beat all content specialty out of the profession. The New New Criticism's insistence that students need only to read and never to take in context or make crucial connections certainly makes it seem like there's no need to have any content knowledge, but of course that quickly devolves into something ridiculous and hollow. “A Modest Proposal” without context is satire without the sideways glance – a bare call for cannibalizing infants that is both confusing and uninteresting beyond its shock value.

I'm appealing to the canon though, and that's tantamount to elitist rearguard knee jerking, right? But how would Stephen Colbert be funny without context – the awareness of the satire, given the absence of a wink? For that matter, how would his show be remotely comprehensible on any level without knowledge of external specifics? Or, to hit at the heart of what matters most to the neo-liberal education “reformers,” are really all about, how would an instruction manual be comprehensible without contextual working knowledge? A lathe worker cannot simply be handed a machine and a manual, no matter how well trained in the ability to decipher texts. A farmer cannot be dumped on a tract of land with a Monsanto starter kit and expect results. Knowledge has to accompany texts or they are at best inefficient ways to convey information; at the worst, they are rendered useless. Of course, that's not really what neo-liberal education theorists are talking about though, is it?

So I'm interested in what Rancière will add to these ideas for me. Is it merely an esoteric summer musing that I only have time for because I'm wrapping up the year? Is it a guise for a process of deconstructing education without simultaneously doing anything real about context in which that system exists? Is it just an excuse for me to tell more stories in class?

Monday, May 13, 2013

Good Luck on the Half Court Shot, Suckers

It seems like these ads just get more and more insulting (antagonistically so?) to students.

Thursday, May 2, 2013

Reading Increasingly Difficult Texts

One of the students I've been tracking has moved from the prose summaries of The Odyssey to the Fitzgerald translation. Compare these annotations from the first pages of Book XXII to the same students' earlier annotations - the second student in my 2 Odyssey Sample Annotations.

The nuance is certainly improving and I don't think I see any of the character confusion found in the earlier example.