It's been the cold hard middle of the second semester - beware the Ides of March and all that. But a good thought yesterday in class . . .
Most of my students decode fairly well. They're non-readers: for the most part, students who cannot make meaning out of words strung together even if they know a large number of the words. It reminds me of my early days of high school Spanish. I had a bit of vocabulary but it took too much processing power to put it all together.
Yesterday, I listened to a student read and heard slow decoding though. He could do it, but at a low level. How is this student supposed to make meaning while working so hard to process individual words? The answer is simple. He has to take some strain off the processor to free up room for individual programs to run. He can annotate just a phrase of a sentence, then move on. He doesn't have to hold nearly as much meaning in his head while decoding the next set of words.
In math, this is a no-brainer, right? We make students write down the steps of the problem so we can check their progress, but also so that they don't have to hold multiple computations in their heads at the same time.
Annotation isn't for writing in a case like this. Annotation is a process related to reading - the actual comprehension of a text.
Welcome to my attempt to teach reading, because I don't think it's really being done anywhere. So . . . I'm trying to do it. I'm documenting my method, process, assessments, some data tracking, and anything else that I can come up with to create a useful and real reading pedagogy.
Tuesday, March 18, 2014
Tuesday, January 21, 2014
Teaching Reading, Teaching Writing, and the Hochman Expository Writing Method
My program's getting changed again. It's the way things go.
Anyway, I've been learning about Judith Hochman and her Teaching Basic Writing Skills, along with the method that goes with it. It's expository writing broken down to the sentence level in a way that makes a tremendous amount of sense. So often - particularly given the NYC focus on Common Core Writing Standard #1 - we've got students writing arguments of one kind or another, going through revision processes, talking big talk, but without an understanding of what a sentence is.
That seems unbelievable, but stodgy old grammarians have been griping about it for years with a bit of sympathy from me. Teaching students to correct - much less avoid - fragments and run-on sentences is a nightmare if they don't have words like dependent clause or even noun and verb in their active lexicons.
I'm not a disciple or anything - just doing some PD when I can - but it seems like Hochman's method for teaching writing lines up with my method of teaching students to break down and annotate texts for comprehension while reading. The link between sentence-by-sentence comprehension of a text has always seemed glaringly related to the process of expository writing, which is how I got cover fire in the early days of the Common Core pre-rollout, using the writing standard #2 and the reading for information standard #2, which basically ask students to explain what a text means and how it conveys that meaning - lots of things about author's craft and rhetorical work. It was good stuff before the hammer came down and everything was around the focus on a position (which used to be a claim, which used to be a thesis) . . .
So hopefully this is relevant and I can do something with it. If any of you bare few out there reading this have any input or thoughts, it's been too long since I've heard from some of you.
Anyway, I've been learning about Judith Hochman and her Teaching Basic Writing Skills, along with the method that goes with it. It's expository writing broken down to the sentence level in a way that makes a tremendous amount of sense. So often - particularly given the NYC focus on Common Core Writing Standard #1 - we've got students writing arguments of one kind or another, going through revision processes, talking big talk, but without an understanding of what a sentence is.
That seems unbelievable, but stodgy old grammarians have been griping about it for years with a bit of sympathy from me. Teaching students to correct - much less avoid - fragments and run-on sentences is a nightmare if they don't have words like dependent clause or even noun and verb in their active lexicons.
I'm not a disciple or anything - just doing some PD when I can - but it seems like Hochman's method for teaching writing lines up with my method of teaching students to break down and annotate texts for comprehension while reading. The link between sentence-by-sentence comprehension of a text has always seemed glaringly related to the process of expository writing, which is how I got cover fire in the early days of the Common Core pre-rollout, using the writing standard #2 and the reading for information standard #2, which basically ask students to explain what a text means and how it conveys that meaning - lots of things about author's craft and rhetorical work. It was good stuff before the hammer came down and everything was around the focus on a position (which used to be a claim, which used to be a thesis) . . .
So hopefully this is relevant and I can do something with it. If any of you bare few out there reading this have any input or thoughts, it's been too long since I've heard from some of you.
Labels:
common core,
literacy
Wednesday, January 8, 2014
A Version of an Ignorant Schoolmaster?
This is a half-formed thought, really. The child of necessity. But it might be exciting.
I got a new student yesterday, 3 days out of DR, with almost no English. It happens. But the question is how I work him in at all, given language obstacles and the fact that we're halfway through a unit. Oh, and I found out about him when he sat down in my class. So I started with a bit of a cop-out. I told him that I wanted to see his general reading abilities. I handed him the text my other students had been working with, a Spanish-English dictionary, and some looseleaf.
I'm terrible.
So I checked in with him quickly a few times while managing my biggest and most needs-intensive class and, honestly, forgot about him for bits of time. By the end of class, he gave me just shy of three sheets of looseleaf with these translations of the first few pages of Aristotle's Metaphysics. I was floored. I guess I often forget that students come literate in reading but illiterate in speech, strange because I would say nearly the same thing about my own Spanish. But it seems to me that I can work with this.
Of course, Rancière and Jacotot came to mind. I was certainly an ignorant schoolmaster at this point, though perhaps a lot closer to the blustery fool type than I'd like to admit. But still, the method might hold something here. Todos los hombres por naturaleza desean aprender. (I would've put in ser instead of aprender . . . I'm not sure if this is intonation or intention or if I'm just wrong).
Is this a student who I can work with along the lines of Jacotot's Calypso could not . . . a word by word translation to learn a language? I feel like the pressures of a huge classroom are going to drown this. How many students did Jacotot have? Rancière never really mentions that, does he?
I always assumed that I would use The Ignorant Schoolmaster in conjunction with my reading and annotation method in an English to English translation, but this seems even more in the spirit of Jacotot's project (at least as Rancière frames it).
I'm terrible.
So I checked in with him quickly a few times while managing my biggest and most needs-intensive class and, honestly, forgot about him for bits of time. By the end of class, he gave me just shy of three sheets of looseleaf with these translations of the first few pages of Aristotle's Metaphysics. I was floored. I guess I often forget that students come literate in reading but illiterate in speech, strange because I would say nearly the same thing about my own Spanish. But it seems to me that I can work with this.
Of course, Rancière and Jacotot came to mind. I was certainly an ignorant schoolmaster at this point, though perhaps a lot closer to the blustery fool type than I'd like to admit. But still, the method might hold something here. Todos los hombres por naturaleza desean aprender. (I would've put in ser instead of aprender . . . I'm not sure if this is intonation or intention or if I'm just wrong).Is this a student who I can work with along the lines of Jacotot's Calypso could not . . . a word by word translation to learn a language? I feel like the pressures of a huge classroom are going to drown this. How many students did Jacotot have? Rancière never really mentions that, does he?
I always assumed that I would use The Ignorant Schoolmaster in conjunction with my reading and annotation method in an English to English translation, but this seems even more in the spirit of Jacotot's project (at least as Rancière frames it).
Saturday, November 30, 2013
This is What I'm Talking About! Using the Annotation Reading Method to Read Hawthorne's Scarlet Letter
So I just got a frantic email from an old student. She waited till a bit late to start reading Hawthorne because she knew that she had the long Thanksgiving weekend to catch up. This is pretty unlike her. I'd also point out that she doesn't generally get challenged by the concrete level of the text. So, when she encountered Hawthorne's dense prose, she freaked out. Here's a version of my reply. This is exactly how students can use the annotation reading method to begin to read Hawthorne's Scarlet Letter, just as they can use it to read any number of difficult texts. My sample annotations of Hawthorne are included below.
Hi ________,
Hi ________,
Oh yeah! I love that Mrs. ______ teaches that novel because it challenges the brightest of the bright. Hawthorne's prose is so hard to get used to (but once you're halfway through or so, it will just seem natural).
Think about how I taught you to read Poe way back in the day and the lessons from 9th grade about reading and annotating, if you remember. Reading a few lines ofThe Odyssey and then writing what was happening, reading a little, writing, etc. The basic idea is to read a very little bit and pay attention to what you DO understand, and then write that down (that's the annotation - the writing what you do know). With Hawthorne, it's one thing to get the sense of what's going on and another to know every single word and phrase that he's using. That's graduate school (or at least advanced undergraduate) level. I know that's hard for you - to not understand everything as you go because you're quite bright - but it's how reading really works. I read on something like a 734th grade level and sometimes I have to gloss over things.
But how do you do this? I've attached 2 documents. One is a sample of how I think you can proceed. The crossed out words and phrases are things that I think you might not know right off. Learn all these words and figure out the meanings of the odd phrases, but do it on the second, third, and fourth time you read the text. For now, you're really looking to understand what's happening. Again, I know that you want to understand everything, but in trying to do that right away, it's shutting you down and you're not getting much of anything. So try this.
The 2nd document I've attached is the whole text in a split version, just like the sample I sent to you. If it helps, read it this way. To cross things out on a computer, highlight them and press "Ctrl" and "shift" and "X" all at once. Or something like that - I've got a Mac. so it's a little different. Or sneak into the school library and print the whole thing off. It's less than 300 pages . . . don't tell anyone I suggested that. :)
|
A The founders of a new colony, whatever |
There’s sad, dreary men with beards and hats.
They’re mixed together with women.
They’re in front of a wooden place with a heavy wooden
door . . . (edifice probably means
building of some kind, because it has a door . . . in Spanish, what does
edificio mean?)
These people founded a new colony
They originally were all about happiness in the beginning
Recognized a necessity
some of the soil to be a cemetery
and some to be a prison
It’s safe to assume that the first people of Boston built
the first prison near Cornhill
Does this mean in the same season that they marked out the
first cemetery?
Nucleus . . . center, right? Like in a cell?
The center of the place was an old churchyard – King’s
Chapel
It’s certain that 15 years later
The jail was stained and old
This gave it a dark and sad look
|
Wednesday, November 20, 2013
Developing Comprehension with Increased Annotation
Another example of using annotating for comprehension from our reading of Edgar Allan Poe's "Tell-tale Heart." Here is an excellent illustration of the way that targeted practice with annotating for comprehension can lead to greater text mastery - in fact, the real lesson here seems to be that sparse annotation can invite misreadings, while slow close reading annotations can help eliminate this type of errors.
This first illustrates the problems with sparse annotating. At first, the errors come from simple problems with pronoun attribution - who's "he"? and who's "I"? questions. That's easier to deal with. However, the problems in real comprehension come up when she starts to speed up in the middle of the passage. It is at this point that she mistakenly determines that Poe's narrator is nice after killing the old man and that this caution is to avoid being caught.
This first illustrates the problems with sparse annotating. At first, the errors come from simple problems with pronoun attribution - who's "he"? and who's "I"? questions. That's easier to deal with. However, the problems in real comprehension come up when she starts to speed up in the middle of the passage. It is at this point that she mistakenly determines that Poe's narrator is nice after killing the old man and that this caution is to avoid being caught.
However, look at this later passage. At this point, the student is really annotating for comprehension line by line. This is the same passage I wrote about previously, where students competed to annotate more than their peers. Look at the difference. By stopping with every sentence - in many cases, with every major clause or phrase - the errors are diminished. Of course, this is a couple lessons later than the first sample, so she's simply had more practice, but it's the practice in the method that seems to be helping.
Labels:
data,
Reading Instruction,
teaching Edgar Allan Poe
Tuesday, November 19, 2013
Annotating Tell-tale Heart with Struggling Readers
Here's a fun assignment. We were reading "Tell-tale Heart" and I had a hard time getting students to write their annotations down - the standard unwillingness to put the words on the page. So I ran a basic reading and annotating lesson - the startup with a question asking them to review an idea from an earlier piece of the text, followed by a group reading and annotation of the short paragraph you can see in this picture. Then, I moved into the 15 minute reading and annotating portion, where students read for content and answer a question. But, I threw in a twist. The student with the most correct annotations and a good answer to the question got a 6 out of 5 for the day. It was a competition. This is what I got from the winner, a girl who hadn't annotated more than 4 sentences on her own previously.
I'm back . . . introducing Schuylerville Preparatory High School
So it's been a minute, but I have good reason. After a lot
of difficulties at my previous school, I decided to take an invitation from a
former colleague to be part of a new high school startup. It's just a 9th
grade - fully public and all that, none of that charter market-driven nonsense
- and it's co-located in Lehman High School, one of the last of the grand old
city High Schools. There's a lot of problems with co-location and I knew
that coming in, but . . . here I am.
My program is interesting because it's truly literacy-focused.
Half of the time, I'm teaching a class on language at the word and
sentence level. The other half of the time, I'm teaching very small and
very intensive English classes
These classes are sort of a mixture of self-contained and
ESL support classes. Basically, it’s a
couple classes where I work with 9 and 6 struggling readers, respectively. It’s fantastic. We’re already showing huge gains. I wish I had a better baseline to put up
here, but it all was thrown at me so quickly, I just jumped right in with the
“Masque of the Red Death” startup. Like
Jacotot’s Telemachus, I just know
that it works because it’s what I’ve done . . . I don’t know that there’s
anything special in it. But it works.
I have lots of ideas . . . some are already underway. This is exciting.
Labels:
Reading Instruction
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)

